Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Dear Sister

Please look at this article and let me know your comments.

http://www.tariqjamil.org/Forum/deviant-groups/fitna-e-gamdi/0/?action=printpage

Salam

Ibrahim

salam br
 
This is just one of the loads of rubbish we can see about scholars when the senders of such objections have actually not spent time to read the opinion and work of the scholar personally and would get involved with a circulated propaganda. As you are aware I have been working closely with Mr. Ghamidi's students including the Renaissance Editor Shehzad Saleem on the lines of the research work done by Mr.Ghamidi since a few years now, I have not found a single issue where I could say he is deviating from Qur'an or the Sunnah of Muhammad sws. Hence at best I can say is to ignore such and to go through the hard work these people have been doing in sincerity to bring the facts to the world  from the original sources of Islam.
 
rgds
h

AOA Brother,
 
I went through the same kind of stuff on a different website and decide to jump in the debate. Rather than refuting whatever was published on that site, i just asked for the evidence of whatever they have written. And the end result was that despite my protests they took the whole forum away from their website while my argument was that this debate shoud remain on the website so that the viewers can decide on their own:
a)  The language they used and the kind of morality shown from most senior members of their website.
b) The evidence of their FATWA against a person.
c)  Evidence in their own school of thougt.
 
So these kinds of things not only show the intellectual condition of the religious people but also their tolerance level and hence the conditions of the muslims.
 
Please take the points raised in the forum one by one and try to find out what actually have been said by the Ghamdi. I am not saying that you will or should agrre to it but at least try to find out what actually he is saying (if you are really interested).
 
To be honest i would have liked to jump into the discussion with these people but i guess I am upto more positive and constructive activities to do for the sake of Allah.
 
If you would to discuss these points or have any further concerns then maybe we can work together for any betterment.
 
W/salaam
Imran[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview