Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Hadith Al-Da’if – 3 (Zaeef hadees)

“Who so ever performed hajj and did not visit my grave, he tortured me”.

According to Allma Nasiuddin Albani this is a ‘maudu’ (fabricated) hadith. Hafiz Zahabi in his book “ Mezaan ul aetadal” describe this hadith to be maudu. Imam Saghai, Imam Zarkashi and Ibn Jauzi have also desribed this hadith a maudu one. Imam Shokani in his book “ Al-faraed al majmooa fil ahadees al maozooa” has also described this as fabricated hadith. The proof for this hadith to be fabricated is that to torture Rasoolullah SWA is kufr and if not kufr atleast it may be desribed as a major sin (gunah e kabeer). Here the question arises, is really not to pay visit to Roza e mubarek SWA (grave of Hazrat Muhammah SWA) is a gunah e kabeer. If the answer is in affirmation it means that to visit roza e mubarek is as obligatory (faraz) as performing hajj, whereas no muslim thinks so. It means to visit at roza e mubarek is to pay respect to Hazrat Muhammad SWA and offer fateha. The Islamic scholars are of the opinion that to pay visit to roza e mubarek, at the most, may be ascertained as ‘mustahab’ (recommended).

[b][/b][b][/b][/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview