Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]I saw answers from MR Rehan and MR Abdullah RAhim (members of Ghamdi team) and it made me quite upset.
They said that [b]evil eye phenomena [/b] is real and authentic.
 They are scholars, so they must have their valid reasonings
But if we believe in it so much, [b]then 
don't you think [/b] it will lead only to [b]superstitious life [/b] and encourage the common public to go to everytime, in the case of mishap, to peer and faqeer???
Through all my life, I always believed that [b]my failures were imtihaan (test) of GOD [/b] , and with confidence on GOD I tried again and succeeded.

All [b]sickness of mine and my famliy[/b], I always considered an imtihaan (test) of GOD and prayed to HIM with confidence and got cured.

[b]But now I am thinking that all those mishap were because of EVIL EYE PHENOMENA:[/b]

[u][i]BECAUSE u have only two kind of people surrounding you when u have good life[/i][/u]: one  envy you (hassad) and many others who admire you with love , like your own parents or siblings etc.

but [b]EVIL EYE PHENOMENA IS SO STRONG THAT IT COULD HIT YOU EVEN THE PERSON PRAISING YOU WITH GOOD INTENTION, AS MENTIONED IN ONE HADEES.[/b],where one sahaba got sick because of sincere praise from other sahaba.

I would argue here only one thing: that when many hadees could be rejected on the basis of &quot;normal wisdom rules (aqal kasoti) and on the basis of Quran, then why not this hadees???

from where in Quran and normal aqal qasoti, we can prove that this hadees could be right???? or phenomena of evil eye is valid??

anyway this is scholars 'job.

for me , I need support for not being a superstitious guy, on the basis of this hadees:

can anybody help???[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview