Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Salam Oosman,

Q:-  Again you put your own words in my mouth. I never said 'it should be prayed'. It is a voluntary thing. I pray late salat in the hope that Allah will accpet it and give me same ajr as that of the original salat.

A:- Salat is obligatory work and it is also obligatory that it must be prayed at its specified times. You told above that late salat gives you [b]SAME AJR AS THAT OF THE ORIGINAL SALAT!! [/b] Then according to you voluntary work(i.e praying due salat) can make up the deficiency of obligatory work(salat should be prayed at its specified time)!!! Could you please give any reference from the Qur’an in support of your whims brother?

Secondly, if offering due salat is not part of our religion(islam), then how can it makes up the deficiency of obligatory Salat prayer, which is one of the pillars of Islam??? Very ridiculous.

Q:- It is His will, He can do what He likes from His mercy. I can only hope. I am not forcing anyone that they must do it. I just said I like to do it. There is no such rule you must do it, I never said that.

A:- Why do you not understand my words brother? Almighty God can accept any thing but never accept any idolatry. [b]The idea of offering due salat does not come from Qur’an, it comes from fabricated hadith. If we follow this then it will be fallen under the category of Shirk with Almighty God. [/b] This is very simple. [b]No one would/will be a law(religious) maker except God. If we follow any other religious law which is not particularly mentioned in the Qur’an and comes from outside sourec, then it will be Shirk with Almighty God. [/b] Why do you not understand this?

Q:- It is only your whim - I never preached that. You missed my point totally! Also never once have I quoted any hadith, so why do you keep bringing it up that I follow fabricated hadith! All my reference is from the Quran. Please stop accusing me of following fabricated hadith or fairy tale. If so, tell me what hadith you are talking about as I do not know it.

A:- Brother, I did not miss any of your points. [b]Why did you come here with your whimsical idea, if you did not want to convey this to others? [/b] Brother, Whether you quoted any hadith or not is not the fact, the fact is that this idea(offering due salat) is not in the Qur’an and also it is against the quranic teachings. This idea totally comes from hadith. [b]Could you please tell me how could you know about due salat, if you not follow hadith?[/b]

You said ‘all my reference is from the quran’. [b]Where did you find this idea about due salat in the Qur’an brother? Pl. give reference.[/b]

You said a lie, because if you don’t follow any hadith besides Quran then you could not know/recommend about due salat. Any one can go through any search engine and find out the hadith of due salat. For example pl. read;

Kitab Al-Salat(Saihi Muslim): Book 4, Number 1449, Book 4, Number 1454, Number 1456, Number 145……….

Minara.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview