Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Salam brother Oosman,

My Quote:- You told above that late salat gives you SAME AJR AS THAT OF THE ORIGINAL SALAT!!

Your reply :- I think I am getting tired of having you quote me on things that I never said. You insist on putting your own words and whims into my mouth. I never said such stuff.

My Answer:- Why do you tell a lie brother? Please read the following portion of your earlier post dated 29th June, 2006. You told; [b]“I pray late salat in the hope that Allah will ACCPET IT AND GIVE ME SAME AJR AS THAT OF THE ORIGINAL SALAT”. [/b] Brother you told a lie. I have no need to understand your immature/whimsical lie about religion.

It appears that generally you do not apply your mind when you write your reply to any question!!!

Q:- And whatever good they do, nothing will be rejected of them; for Allâh knows well those who are Al-Muttaqûn 3.115.

A:- [b]You can do good thing, but you can’t import or invent any religious idea from outside source besides Qur’an and label them as Islamic or called them good thing of Islam[/b]. If you do this, this will be Shirk with God, which HE will never forgive. You can’t make any law. The only law maker regarding religion is only God.

[4:48]   GOD does not forgive idolatry, but He forgives lesser offenses for whomever He wills. Anyone who sets up idols beside GOD, has forged a horrendous offense.

Q:- I don't need some hadith to tell me that offering prayers is a good thing.

A:- You brother tried by hook or by crook to avoid the main point here. [b]I never told you that we need help of some hadith to know that offering  prayer is good. It is a command from Almighty God that we must offer our regular salat at its specified times. [/b] But Almighty God does not say anywhere in the Quran that  we should offer missed prayer at any time in the day. [b]This idea comes from outside source i.e. fabricated hadith. 
You did not reply my question yet, which I posed you through my earlier post. My question was “how could you know about due salat, if you do not follow hadith?” [/b] Don’t try to bypass my question by hook or by crook.

Q:- Let me ask you, how many times has Allah said in the Quran to do dhikr (mentioning his Name, remembering Him, glorifying Him)? Salat gives you a chance to do just that.

Answer:- You can mention/remember/glorify His name at any time but salat should be offered at specified times, not any times in the day according to your whims. Why do you not understand this simple words?

Q:- If I miss my salat, I do it later, all I am doing is dhikr in my salat, and if you think this is shirk, then you are really twisted.

A:- You can do what you like, it is your choice. [b]But you can’t say what you do that is Islamic[/b]. [b]The idea of praying due salat is fabricated idea comes from hadith. If you follow this hadith then you are doing Shirk with Almighty God, because you are following fabricated hadith beside only Quran as your religious source.[/b] So brother I don’t twist anything rather you.

Minara.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview