Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Tilawat Said: Firstly, Quran does not put any limit on the number of wives you can have at a time. It exhorts you to have as many wives as you can have, by saying "Have two,two, three, three".

YOU ARE WRONG!!!

Firstly, don’t choose the isolated and your required words. See the full sentence ie before and after your chosen words. Then you will understand the matter. Secondly two two, three three or four four is wrong but two, three or four. Have a look at the Arabic text also (if you know) or see the translation of the downloadable Arabic with English Quran at:  www.islamasoft.co.uk/downloads.html  which you must not deny.

Tilawat Said: Does it not mean literally that you can't have a single wife?

Aren’t you honest? Have you not read the complete verse- “If you fear least you become unfair, then you shall be content WITH ONLY ONE or with what you already have”.

Oosman translated [4:3]: “It is not asking to marry their mothers, but asking to marry the orphans under their care!”

YOU ARE ALSO WRONG!!!

For instance, the age of the orphan girls is two years when her father dies and the responsible man or the caretaker is of 50 years. “So, that girl when she reaches puberty, should the man or the caretaker at the age of near about 70 years marry that girl?” Would the people of modern ages, accept this atrocity of handing over a teenager girl to an old man?

******According to your wrong concept, “What should be the solution if the orphans are not girls but boys?” How will you accommodate the boys who have the DOUBLE SHARE than the girls? The verse [4.3] says “AND IF YOU FEAR that you cannot act equitably towards orphans, then marry SUCH WOMEN”. Now tell me, WHERE IS THE MORE FEAR to act equitably- towards single share or double share? So why are you ignoring boys who have the double share where there may be MORE FEAR, if Quran says, “AND IF YOU FEAR……….”******

Surely Allah doesn’t do the injustice it is only the man who for one’s own benefits does the all by hook or crook. So those who do wrong translations to marry the girls and ignore the boys, they are actually worshipping their own LUST AND THE WHIM not God. Hence they are surely Mushrik.

Oosman said: It is for Allah to judge who does what, and it is not your place to call me idol worshipper.

Allah will judge you according to Quran only. Do not say indirectly that there is no law of God. But if the law is present (which surely is and clearly defined- Quran) you will have to obey that otherwise you are surely a sinner. If you do not follow Quran, you are surely doing shirk with God. And if you say, “It is for Allah to judge who does what” then there is no need of any religion as every sane human knows what is good and what is bad.

BOTH, Tilawat and oosman, you are WRONG, see Arabic text of the verse or the excellent reply of Minara.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview