Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Salaam all

Usmani 790, without meaning to be rude, Your logic is very flawed (whether it is your aqil or you are simply of closed mind).
The answer to the simple contradictions I posted was a very bizzarre story of the blind men and elephant. 
Ok let us play the game with your rules (regardless of the fact how ridiculous they are):-  I dont know how many blind people you know, but the most that i have come across are NOT STUPID to guess the shape of an object without feeling all of it. If any blind person (with any semblance of any intelligence) was to feel an elephant they would try to feel all of it (if it was possible) becuse elephants legs, tail, body etc are not detached from each other that the blind person will not be able to detect their continuity. No sane blind person would comment on a shape of any object that they were unable to feel fully. So your lephant example is a smoke screen for a very obvious contradiction which you appear unable to grasp.

To make matters even more simpler for you or any one else I will simplify the issue even further and remove the bit about body washing(as you guys obviousouly cannot cope with more than 1 issue at time) and just ask which of the Djall's eye was missing. Because your beloved hadiths are bit confused. If you have difficulty formulating n answer you have 2 simple choices:-
(1) Admit you have no idea how to explain this balatant contradiction.

(2) Hadiths are obviousouly contradictory hence one must be wrong.

However I have feeling you will again not adress the point raised but ramble on about something completely irrelevent (which the corruptors of Islam have mastered to hide their obvious illogicality and their lack of understanding of the Quran).

Incidentally your  Mr Singh joke was crude and racist (even though you are unikely to even understand this point). All of the Singhs I know possess far more logic and intelligence than you have shown in your answerds.
regards

Edited by: ibrahim on Thursday, November 23, 2006 9:01 AM[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview