Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]salaam all, my question is for brother shamsher, i would like to know why you do not belive in the hadiths, apart from your obvious reply it being man made, why do you not belive in it.
the hadiths as i see it is just telling us in detail about the life of the Prophet pbuh it tells how the Prophet pbuh practiced the commands of Allah SWT which were given to him through revelations. we all agree the Quran is complete, but does not the hadiths co-inside with the quran? just giving us fuller details on how best to carry out acts? or just follow the acts by the best example to mankind the Prophet PBUH?.
Hadiths is man made its true but alot ofstuff that is in the hadiths comes from the quran only difference being it goes into more depth, it shows us mere mortals how best to carry out acts of worship or things that affect everyday life for a muslim. Sunnah started from the days of Prophet Abrahim AS, which has been passed down from generation to genration, untill it came down to the last messenger Prophet Mohammed PBUH who then re-instated some things,ultered others and brought in more stuff that Allah SWT commaneded him to do so. so then why before the prophet PBUH was sunnah accpeted after all it was man made meaning after the Prophet Abrahim AS people continued the sunnah from generation to generation on what basis, their great great grnadfathers use to do it? it was passed down from word of mouth, also through other messengers, there was no Quran sharif then, so why did people follow it? my point is the hadiths can not be all wrong especially if it works along side of the Quran sharif.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview