Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Salaam

[quote] Quran is preserved book as assured by Allah.
the same is not true with ahadith. [/quote]

True, but also hadith have nothing to do with Gods word (as you have pointed out below)

[quote] Errors are very natural in a work done by human being.
All we can do is to find out logical reasons to point out those errors. [/quote]

True (at least we seem to be getting somewhere at last with you anyway). 
so far so good but:

[quote] Throwing the precious work just because of some human errors isnt judicious. [/quote]

Unfortunately like many you find it very difficult to let go of your life long held prejudices. 
If hadith books were just an attempt to record Prophet Mohammeds life history there would not be an issue. Unfortunately the problem is that the hadith, by the vast majorit anyway, have become part of Islam and are put almost on par with the Quran. It does not matter what pearls of wisdom may be contained within some hadith, the [b]fact that they  portray the prophet as a paedophile, condoning rape & torture[/b] amongst many other disgusting scenarios mean that they can never be part of islam. Unless you think that these things are acceptable. By far the hadith have been the biggest culprit in corrupting islam and creating divisions within it. 
Majority of muslims are not even vaguely aware how contradictory the hadith are or how derogarotry they are towards the prophet. Unfortunately when some of them discover these facts there prejudices are too deeply set and then despite these obvious flaws they continue to argue the ridiculous point: Ah yes there are some trashy hadith (as this is obvious even to them) but here are some good ones as well so must keep them part of Islam. If people cannot see the flawed logic in this arguement then truly their mind, heart etc are sealed as predicted in the Quran.

Regards[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview