Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Salam,

Quote:- He then built on his asserted discovery of what Kassim Ahmad on page 68 refers to as “THE MIRACLE OF CODE 19” TO ASSERT FURTHER THAT THIS REVELATION TO HIM FROM ALLAH PROVED THAT HE WAS A PROPHET. HE DEVELOPED THIS TO ASSERT THAT HE WAS THE FIFTH MOST IMPORTANT PROPHET, RIGHT AFTER ABRAHAM, MOSES, JESUS, AND MUHAMMAD. He then proceeded to introduce new customs, like encouraging women to lead the prayers of both men and women together. As a result he was assassinated.

REPLY:- Nowhere Rashad Khalifa claimed that he is a PROPHET.

Quote :- He cautions that, “A return to the Qur’an does not mean that we destroy all the books of hadith and all the books of the religious scholars, nor do we mean that we no longer need the religious scholars. It only means that we must refer to the Qur’an alone as infallible guidance.”

REPLY : - Dr. Robert D. Crane did not say any new thing. Also Rashad Khalifa told that “WE SHOULD NOT ACCEPT ANY OTHER SOURCE AS SOURCE OF LAW(RELIGIOUS) OF ISLAM BESIDES QUR’AN.  It is true that we can’t take hadith, mishna, zemarrah…etc..etc. as our RELIGIOUS SOURCE OF ISLAM. Our only religious source is Only the Qur’an and nothing else.

2ndly, we should not follow the opinion of any scholars regarding our religion BLINDLY. We have to use our sense, we have to judge the opinion of religious scholars with the Nobel Qur’an to know whether it is right or wrong.

Peace
Samsher.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview