Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote][quote]
And as regards the prophets response to his wife when she asked him who told him, the answer can be taken as "The All knowing and fully acquainted made me know (made it known to me) (nabba'ny)"...  To understand it any other way is to contradict: -[/quote]Naba means to inform something which is not observed. Quran use the word Naba only for the stories of Prophet and news of the Hour, check these ayat. Naba cannot be observed event.
6:34  7:175  9:70 10:71 14:9 25:69 27:22  28:3 38:21&67 49:7 53:36  78:2 etc
So, this Allah SW informed something to Prophet PBUH, not made to observe.
[quote]

So even if for argument's sake we were to posit that Allah TOLD him (which Allah makes no claim of), then it STILL would not be a part of our guidance as it is not a part of the Qur'an.[/quote] You have to provide proof for this, just making persistent claim is useless.

It is fact that Allah SW have informed Prophet something which is not their in Quran. Your claim is proven wrong from the word naba. 
Further, regaeding wife beating. On what basis you claim that your explanation have to be accepted and hadith has to be rejected. 
Let me summarise.
1. Ayah of Surah tehreem, and specifically use of word Naba proved that, Allah SW have revealed something to Prophet which is not there in Quran. 
2. On what basis you say that, with regard to wife beating issue, we have to accept your explanation and reject hadith. Whoever accept you will pass the trial and whoever accept hadith fails the test of Allah SW.
3. You have given so many possible meaning of daraba, does not it mean that we need some authentic explanation of Quran from Prophet? Otherwise why Allah SW decided to confuse his servents.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview