Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote][quote]sister, Bukhari, Muslim and Abu Daud differ in their collection of ahadith considered as authentic. Shiat believe in ahadith of Hazrat Ali as authentic.no problem. till you say ahadith become a source of religion.[/quote]

I don't consider Ahaadeeth to be a source of religion, though there [b]is[/b] guidance in them.

Quote:
"quote:

the Prophet (SAW) at first did not allow his Companions to write down his words. But later on, he did

what is the proof of this? Another hadith?!!"

No. In fact, I don't have any proof. But this is a part of history. You read the Holy Prophet's (SAW) biography and you get to know that later on he did allow his words to be written down.

Quote:
The hadith were collected several hundred years after the prophet passed away. had he given permission in his lifetime, then why did people wait so long?

Allah knows the answer to this question. But I think this was because of the fact that during the Holy Prophet's (SAW) time, his Companions (RA) had preserved the Ahaadeeth pretty well, so there was no great need of compiling them. A few hundred years later, many people began to corrupt the Ahaadeeth by fabricating them, adding and subtracting from them. So Imaam Bukhari, by the Grace of Allah, took up the task of collecting the uncorrupted Ahaadeeth, and he [b]was[/b], Alhamdulillaah successful.

And Allah knows best.
Wassalaam.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview