Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Brother Waseem Walikum Salam

Quote:-Why is there a difference in collection of ahadith by Bukhari, Muslim and Abu Daoud?

What do you mean by difference in collection, could you please elaborate it further.

Quote:-on what criteria do you negate the ahadith form hazrat Ali. because they are contrary to the sunni belief. If we believe in one group we cannot accept ahadith form the other group.

There are many ahadith narrated by Hazrat Ali in famous collection of ahadith.If you will read the Fazail-e-Amaal of Tabligi people, you will find the lots of ahadith from Ahle bait as well.So its not correct to say that we negate the ahadith from Hazrat Ali.its shia who don’t accept the ahadith narrated by sahabah but only few.They believe that after Prophethood ended at our Prophet(pbuh) then the Imamat has taken over it and Imam must be from the Prophet family.So what ever imam says him self or what Imam tell some thing from Prophet(pbuh) can only be accepted as a source of deen other than Quran.This is what I know about them.

Brother After reading your whole reply what I will request you to make a habit of your life that in every matter of Deen and Dunia specially where you have any problem please just spare 5 minutes and talk to Allah about it in little bit details.Ask Him guide you on where haq is.Ask forgiveness to Allah on what we used to do wrong in daily life.What ever dua you want to ask Allah,ask Him.This you do before you sleep every day is better.

Allah wants to be sincere and how much one have desire to be guided.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview