Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Salaam aboosait

What is your point?

[quote] Trained Islamic scholars are much more likely to adopt a critical stance towards even the sahih collections, and caution that hadith have to be weighed and evaluated, not accepted as true without further consideration.  [/quote]

I still dont think you have understood a very simple point I have made.
My point was simply that these stories are GARBAGE and if any literature has this garbage then it cannot be accepted as divine or even anything to do with Islam. Any religious literature or beliefs have to be judged in their entirety not to pick and choose what you consider to be acceptable.

“ [quote] Today, the situation is different. The collections of ahadeeth have for the most part stabilized, and with the advent of the printing press, the collections are easily mass-produced. There is a blessing in all this of course, but there is a real danger that Muslims will fall under the impression that owning a book or having a [b]database is equivalent to being a scholar of ahadeeth.[/b] This is a great fallacy. Therefore, we would like to warn you that this database is merely a tool, and not a substitute for learning, much less scholarship in Islam.”  [/quote]

Your point is what?
Who is talking about becoming a scholar. WE are discussing whether hadith have any bases to be considerd as part of Islam.
If you want to discuss how to become a sholar in hadith or whatever start a new thread.

[quote] *(The Muslim Students Association of the U.S. and Canada is also known as MSA National. It is an umbrella organization for all of the chapters at various campuses across the continent)  [/quote]

??????????

[quote] You are adviced to learn the science of hadeeth before making a fool of yourself in public forums. [/quote]

You obviousouly have not so far!

Let us see. You believe that hadith are divine and then you accept that some of them are pure trash. However some of your so called scholars also find these hadith unpalatabel i.e they are complete lies. So learning or not learning (you have no idea what any one has learned or not learned) the science of hadith is going to change this fact...exactly how?

PS...You still have not commnented on how your Quranic reference support the validity of hadith. But then you appear to have a problem sticking to any particular point...I suppose that is how one does not make a fool of oneself.

regards[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview