Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Salam mr. Khan,

MY Quote:Qur’an is the only religious source of Islam. If anything, yes anything we regard as religious source besides Qur’an, then it will be proved that we are doing shirk with Almighty Allah because we are not satisfied with the Qur’an only, Almighty Allah’s words, so we seek another source to complete the islam. Islam was completed with the revelation of Qur’an. So we should not require anything to further complete our religion, which has already been completed.

your reply :- The fact needs serious consideration that he source of religion untill the Day of Judgement will now remain the Qura'n and the teachings of its bringer, Muhammad sws, which have been guarded just as Qura'n itself as Sunnah which was preceded by Qura'n as Sunna t e Ibrahimi and forwarded by Muhammad sws after purification;

MY REPLY :- Brother khan, where did you find that “Sunnah  was preceded by Qura'n as Sunna t e Ibrahimi and forwarded by Muhammad sws after purification”. You people always used to give whimsical opinion regarding Islam, which has no support/reference in the whole Qur’an. Brother true Islam can only find in the Qur’an. Do you not read and understand what the verse 22:67 says? Let us see what this verses of Qur’an says about the subject;

[red][22:67]   For each congregation, we have decreed a set of rites that they must uphold. Therefore, they should not dispute with you. You shall continue to invite everyone to your Lord. Most assuredly, you are on the right path.[/red]

This ayat in fact confirms that we the receivers of the Qur’an are to follow the rites and rules given to us in the Qur’an and not what was given to those before us….God tells us clearly here that every people(congregation) were given their won set of rites……as a result to say that we follow the identical rites that were given to Ibraheem and that were passed down to us in contradiction to this ayat….

Now we come to a very significant pharase in the above ayat………. Lets look at the pharase “Therefore, they should not dispute with you.”….what does God mean by this pharase?

Well, let us first try to imagine why those of previous congregation/scripture would dispute with Muhammad? After all the scripture that is given to Muhammad(Quran) advocates the same one God that those people believe in, so why should they dispute with him?

It is obvious that they will dispute with him because according to the Qur’an which Muhammad follows, he is following different rites and rules than what they are following……….for that they are not happy and they dispute with him……….this once again indicates that what Muhammad was given was different from what ws practiced at his time, otherwise they would not dispute with him……what this also proves is that to say that God commanded Muhammad to follow the identical practices of Abraham which it is claimed that were known and practiced at the time, this is a totally false statement.if Muhammad was to follow what was known and practiced at the time(and which some say was preserved from the time of Abraham) they why would the people of the previous scripture would dispute with him? Would they dispute with him if he was following what was known and practiced at the time??? the only reason that they will dispute with him is that what he was given(Qur’an) brought new and different rites and rules to what they were given ….this is confirmed with the words;

“For each congregation, we have decreed a set of rites that they must uphold”.

Quote:- and Hadith literature supports, mind us just Supports, does not add anything, to the teachings from these two basic sources.

MY REPLY:- How could you or in what manner you offer your regular salat? How could you observe Ablution(wudu), How many times in a day do you offer your obligatory salat…etc..etc..

After your reply I will show you InshAllah whether your cherished hadith added anything to the real islam or not.

Samsher,India.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview