Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Salam all,

Brother Roushan ..P/1

Quote: why these people (quran only group)has so much enthusiasm and zeal in denouncing Hadith.

Reply: Brother I could not reply earlier as I was out of city, what I understand the reasons are following in this regard and this is my understanding…whether one should accept or reject it.

When Allah created human being He says that we should live on this earth for a time period and after that we will be returned to Allah for a reward of Heaven or Hell for what we have done. Our whole test will depend upon a GUIADNACE from Allah that how should we follow that in case of TRUTH AND FALSEHOOD.
In this regard He will guide us through ourselves (human being), He will choose man among ours and give them guidance in FORM of message, scripture, signs…etc. through WAHI and  we will know the way that leads to God commandments.

On the other side Allah has given all characters in the creation of human being to accept or reject, Hate or Love, obey or disobey, Kindness or Unkindness, Proud or Humble….etc. to follow or disfollow him. He (human being) has been given all authorities of power in this regard.

Here the only thing is WAHI between Allah and His MESSENGERS which he sends to his chosen messengers to deliver message among the people. We have been said to obey that message. Now this message can be in  form of SCRIPTURE, SINGS, WISDOM, EVEN WITHOUT ANY SCRIPTURE, given to those messengers through WAHI.

The FORM OR TYPE OF MESSAGE DOES NOT KEEP ANY IMPORTANCE, it may be in sings, wisdom, scripture, or even without scriptures. The only concerned thing should be the MESSAGE, or the SIGNS, or WISDOM or ALL in ONE person.

Now above things have been given to the messengers, and make one (messenger) Superior to other (human being) by ranking. And other people have been said to follow THE ONE PERSON because of these all i.e message, signs..etc guidance for them.

Now when they (messengers) become superior in ranking than we human, just because of the message which they have brought, THEN these (rejcetors) people become JEALOUS.

So they (rejectors) think that y those (messengers) have been made messenger, why not they? As they were like them too, Why they should obey his sayings and doings.

So this is the basic reason which changes into more shapes, like to obey the messenger is only to obey the message what they messengers brought.

Actually this sense is also right, but it is half, and the complete one is to obey the both Message i.e Scripture & Messenger as personal too. Because if u see, we obey what a messenger speaks from his mouth, then he tell us that this is Quran and these are his sayings. He is true to his words. If we believe a person’s speaking spoken as Quran THEN why not we can obey a person’s sayings, or doings, as situation is the same. As for as the sayings and doings as personal of a messenger’s are concerned, mainly they may be of two types, ONE which is spoken or did for GUIADANCE OR RELIGION source AND other for his daily life.   A layman can easily differentiate b/w the both easily, which are for guidance and which are for his person life.
But rejecters do not accept this to say that there is no personal obedience of a messenger, we agree that we have no personal obedience other than the guidance for Religion, the guidance which is given to him is also a FORM OF WAHI, 
Where ever Allah speaks in Quran like that “HE sends WAHI to his messenger, or He who is messenger does not speak but a WAHI sent to him”, totally does not mean THAT everyplace in Quran word “ WAHI “ stands for REVELATION or QURAN. It also mean WAHI/INSPIRATION other than QURAN. When word WAHI is mentioned, if it is supported by or mentioned as SCRIPTURE, before or after it, then there its meaning is Quran, and if it is not so THEN it is also guidance OTHER THAN QURAN for us. We have been said to obey THE WAHI. And this way both are received from ONE PERSON. BUT ACTUALLY THERE IS ONE THING and that is WAHI.
(Note: This definition is given by a Well Know scholar, Syed Moulana Abulalla Moudodi in his book “ Sunnah ki Aani Haisiyat”).

Continue…P/2 for Brother Roushan[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview