Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Continue…P/2 for Brother Roushan

…We see that a messenger can bring a scripture, and even can come without any scripture first, so when he comes without a scripture then what is thing by which he (messenger) guides people? Then answer to this is that he is INSPIRED/WAHI, through which he guide us. SO IT IS PROVED THAT A MESSAGE WITHOUT ANY SCRIPTURE CAN BE GUIDANCE OR SOURCE OF RELIGION brought by the messengers.

And these rejectors also agreed that Prophet Muhammad received INSPIRATION/WAHI, however they do not agree.   Alas!

So HOW CAN THESE PEOPLE WHO ARE BEATING THE DRUM OF SCRIPTURE…SCRIPTURE….SCRIPTURE… “THE ONLY SOURCE FOR GUIADANCE”, accept that a messenger can guide the HUMAN BIENG without any SCRIPTURE.??? ( the messengers who have not been given scripture).
 
Here they say that “ messengers who do not bring scriptures, promote previous scriptures” but they have not even a single proof to that.
SO we see that actually this is not their problem, the root problem is that THEY DO not WANT TO OBEY A MESSAGE FROM A PERSON LIKE THEM, THIS IS THE MOST UNFAVOURABLE CONDITION FOR THEM THAT THEY DO NOT LIKE.

These  persons would obey if the MESSAGE IS DIRECTLY SAID TO THEM BY ALLAH, but They do not like to obey it if there is one in MIDTH OF this message, and who is also a person like them.
So this is the Sunnah of Allah to make human being/ Jinn HIS obedience indirectly, and this is a testing from Allah.

You have read in holy Quran in many places that people asked messengers why Allah did not speak to THEM directly, WHY DID HE SEND MESSENGERS?
Or You (messengers) should not have been from ours/human being as we all would have been considered equally, SO THEY WANT TO SAY as they are ready to OBEY the message IF THE PERSON SHOULD HAVE CHANGED according to their choice or messengers should not have been from humans.

Therefore such persons (REJECTORS OF HADITH & SUNNAH) try to remove the LABEL of being one’s messengership, to make him (messenger) equal to them as they feel that we all are equal, no prophet no messenger but just MESSEGE…they hate messengers when THEY are not considered equal to messengers/prophets.

Therefore they try to find different ways THAT y should they OBEY a messenger other than the MESSAGE i.e SCRIPUTRE.
By God if they see there is also a message from the messengers as personal for guidance of human kind, they never said that these people should have wash their cups and clothes.

This is my understanding whether any one agree or not….there are many more reasons but I see, THE MAJOR REASON IS THAT MOST OF HUMAN BEING DO NOT WANT to follow others INSTRUCTIONS,
YES THEY WILL ACCEPT IF THE PERSON IS CHOSEN BY THEM, or if the COMMANDMENTS ARE ACCORDING TO THEIR WHIMS OR WILLS, then such people will obey. 
Therefore SUCH people do not like past people too, their understandings, their works or jobs made in this regard.
THEY WANT TO GET RID OF ALL THAT. Why should they take A BIG BURDEN of  Sunnah, Hadith, Ijma, Qiyas…etc, they become very bore when they see a lot before them, and become confused when they think that they should consult to Ulmas, Scholars, …etc. therefore this is their shortcut to run behind the door.

Salam
Cares..[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview