Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Cont…P/3
Quote: Now please see if I translate the verse 3:81 according to your whims, then let us see what will be the meaning of the verse;

“GOD took a covenant from the prophets, saying, "I will give you the scripture and wisdom. Afterwards, Muhammad will come to confirm all existing scriptures( not deliver a new scripture) You(including Muhammad because he was a prophet) shall believe in him(Muhammad) and support him(Muhammad) {that means Muhammad believed & support on himself}" He said, "Do you agree with this, and pledge to fulfill this covenant?" They(including Muhammad) said, "We agree."(that means Muhammad was also agreed the above covenant that he supports & believed on himself!!!!) He said, "You have thus borne witness, and I bear witness along with you."

Reply: No it should so, see

“ God took a covenant from the prophets, saying, “ I will give u the scripture and wisdom. Afterwards, Muhammad will come to confirm which u (previous prophets posses). You (prophets other than Muhammad because he is not encluded) shall believe in him (Muhammad) and support him (Muhammad), he said “ do u (prophets other than Muhammad) agree with this, and pledge to fulfill this coenant?”. They (not encluding Muhammad) said, “ We agree, (prophets other than Muhammad agreed). He said, “ you have thus borne witness, and I bear witness along with u”.

Quote: Then according to your same logic after 500 + years later Almighty God took the covenant from Muhammad. Isn’t ?

Reply: Allah did not take a covenant from Muhammad of such type, because there is no messeger to come after him. And this covenant is concerned about a new messenger coming. So there is no such covenant mentioned in Holy Quran, as no messenger has to come.

Quote: 2ndly, Almighty Allah took the covenant from US also (as you opined). Then according to your logic Almighty God took this covenant separately from you from me…..from all people past, present one by one and will be taken from future people one by one. Isn’t? What a logic!!!

Reply: Brother I do not mean so exactly as u mentioned, I mean Allah can do so and as for our covenant is concerned see the following verse:-
(2:84),2:187,5:12,4:54, 5:7,5:14

Quote: Oh…. Your reply? you could not yet provide any quranic verse in support of your whims till date rather conjecture. When you will be able to provide reference from the Qur'an, you pl. tell me, I shall Inshallah response you.

Reply: Thanx brother that u have given ur precious time to response, I really appreciate, thx.

I don’t know what type of quranic verses u want to know that prove ur whims, as several times all the members mentioned Quranic verse in the regard of subject, but always u run to say that give quranic prove, I do not know what is ur understanding.

One thing more, I appreciate u type of persons hardworking that u made in this regard to remove sunah & hadith, and it seems also that u people first gathered  or collected“ all the materials” I mean objections, interpretations, understanding…etc of all type of muslims belonging to Sunahh, hadith..etc AND then u gave GOOD TIME, VERY GOOD TIME, to set up a system WHICH HOW OPPOSE THEIR SYSTEMS, i.e Sunah & Hadith.
In this way u have adopted ur religion “ FIRST AND THEN WENT THROUGH THE QURAN and TURNED ITS (QURAN) FACE TOWARDS TO UR WISHES” to prove that. Is’nt?.

But u are not completely succeded in ur mission. Because what one wish never be done until Allah wills.

I think in this regard if some one has to know about ur whims and to proov them false HE ALSO HAVE TO GIVE A GOOD TIME to it, and should first know all ur whims and interpretations. Then inshallah he will be more able to judge u well.

Sincerely speaking, brother I m not a learned or scholar man, just a student, but I knew this that u are not on the right path, but Allah knows the best that who is on right path.

Thx again,

Take care,

Cares…[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview