Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Sallam all,
Brother cares

Quote: this is nothing but ur whim brother. U people have made this whim to support ur R.K to make a messenger, because he did not brought any new scripture. Therefore he was not fitting to be a messenger. And u made this whim to support him to be a messenger. This is nothing but whim.

MY REPLY:- Don’t be excited brother. I can also say you as you say that ‘you people made your whim to support your idol Muhammad to make him the last messenger’, when it is not true according to Qur’an. I have given you numerous references from the Qur’an in support of my statement that “Whenever God mentions prophethood in the Qur’an, HE mentions scripture and sometimes wisdom” e.g. (3:79, 6:89, 29:27,45:16, 57:26). But blind like you can’t see this light. Also all messengers did not/do not bring scripture(s) e.g. 3:81 also messenger Hood, Saleh…

Quote:- Where as Allah says in many places that he sends the scriptures to both MESSENGERS and PROPHETS separately and it is a real truth that can not seen by u type of persons.

MY REPLY:-  Where brother??? Where brother, Almighty Allah says that ‘He sends the scriptures to BOTH MESSENGERS AND PROPHETS SEPARATELY”?? Why had you not been able to give any single reference from the Qur’an in support of your statement?? I know why. Because it is OBVIOUS LIE and for that you people never find any reference in support of it.

Quote:  No brother, As Allah says, he sent scriptures to both messengers and prophets too, and when no messenger and prophet are to come, then no scripture will come. So Qur’an is the last scripture.

MY REPLY:- smile. At first pl. show me a single reference from the Qur’an wherein Almighty says(as you claimed) that “He sent scriptures to both messengers and prophets separately”. I know you can’t be able. Please go and try…..carry on……. Also I never claimed by saying that Qur’an is not the last scripture. Don’t speak lie after lie.

Quote: brother ur explanation of verse 3:81 is wrong, try to understand.
Here God tells the people that he took covenant from the ( previous ) prophets (not all- u deliberately add word “all” to it )

MY REPLY:- Verse 3:81 says that Almighty Allah took the covenant from the PROPHETS. HE did not say here that He took the covenant from the PREVIOUS PROPHETS!!!(if yes, then provide reference) Why do you ADD here your own words(whims), which is not found in the Qur’an??? HE said that HE took the covenant from the PROPHETS  that means He took that….. and also from Muhammad as he was also a prophet. Very simple, but I amazed why you people can’t understand this very simple sentence!!!

Quote:- in every age that a messenger will come after them one by one,

REPLY:- Could you pl. tell me what do you mean here by saying “in every age a messenger will come”. Please provide reference from the Qur’an in support of your opinion.

Quote:- when one comes HE again takes the covenant from the current to say that after him (this messenger) a new messenger will come, so and so. As coming of Muhammad (PBUH) is mentioned in Torah and Injil,

MY REPLY:- This is not the rule. It is your own whims, because Qur’an does not support this and also does not certify that every messenger prophet told in every scripture regarding the future coming messenger prophet. Whatever may be, for the sake of argument if I accept your whimsical theory, then I can say or it is proved that; In 3:81 “Qur’an (through the mouth of Muhammad) also says that “After the prophets  A messenger will come to CONFIRM THE SCRIPTURES” that means he(the incoming) messenger, who will come after the PROPHETS, will only confirm the existing scriptures, not delivered a news scripture. Then why do you not understand this simple clear meaning of the verse concerned???

To be continued………….[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview