Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Salamat says:They might not be able to counter him, but that decision i.e. whether they are able to or not should be left to the program. Whats the point of Pre-supposing it?

Reply: For any discussion, participant must be equal in scholastic level. The theme of program seems to me are to present the opinions of Ghamidi Sahib on the base of arguments.

The traditional scholars do not have proper understanding of the principles on which Ghamidi Sahib presents his sum ups. These scholars do not have preparations to counter him on the base of arguments from Quran & Sunnah.

They just came out one the base of surface knowledge about him that he is denier of Hadith, fellow of west, a modernist etc.

AJJ ISLAM program having topic ISLAMIC STATE was aired a year ago .The participant were Dr.Israr and Ghamidi Sahib.Dr.Israr has good sound knowledge of religion and contemporary world. That was really worth seeing program .Ghamidi Sahib had to work hard to present his opinions before him.

Therefore, such programs should be exemplified for better understanding of two opinions.

I hope, I might have cleared you.

Salamat: I think lets not go into personal matters, what do you say?

Reply: You are absolutely right. I have presented this objection in the light of contemporary Islamic intelligentsia. You must be agree that simplicity has worth in Islam and being a part of great Islamic scholar these minors things hold major impact. What do you say?[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview