Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]A schalor;s views may looks more revelent in the basis on his aruments but there is always posiblity that in the eyes of Quran and Sunnah it may be wrong.

Brother Islam is not based on some one personnel opinions no matter how good knowledge person may have.If he saying some thing on a very basic and important issue of the religion and not providing any reference from Quran and Sunnah even after many requests of mine,his views and opinion may be important to you but for me his own views and opinions without Quran and Sunnah have no value.

What happened in that forum please see again.I really wish to know where did I mistake so in future I will be careful.It will be a great help.

You wrote:-Fourthly, please elaborate on the words of the Hadith, I dont quite understand, because if it is "what I like it is from Allah" - so anything that I like (I may not be a very pious person) becomes part of my religion, because it is from Allah? Can religion be defined like that?

I wrote:-Now you have problem with the prophet(pbuh) words also,

You reply:-Brother you being student of one of the pupils of a great scholar like Maulana Taqi Usmani, should not indulge in lame accusations in order to win your case.

I wrote:-What I said to you just because one should not pass such remarks on the Prophets words.I did not accused you but commented on your own words you wrote.They were not appropriate at all, ask any one else if you still not sure.

Could you please tell me I did this because I win to my case?Do you know what is in my heart? Certainly you did not and this what is called accusation and may be some thing more than that.

You wrote:- The rest of what you wrote, My reply to it is that I am speechless at your elequaonce, knowledge and your attitude towards handling criticism.

Can see here that how you accused me but where did I accuse you, please show me.

Thank you[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview