Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Salam,

In continuation of my earlier reply……………..

Quote:  No it should so, see

“ God took a covenant from the prophets, saying, “ I will give u the scripture and wisdom. Afterwards, Muhammad will come to confirm which u (previous prophets posses).

MY REPLY :- The meaning of the above sentence is nothing but conjecture because your created interpretation says us that [u]‘God took a covenant from the PROPHETS by saying I will give you the scripture and wisdom’ and then says AFTERWARDS Muhammad will come..!!! [/u] that means your created interpretation of the verse clearly says that Muhammad was not prophet!!!, because the covenant was taken from PROPHETS and if he is not included in covenant,then definitely he was not prophet!!!!

2ndly, your created interpretation also says us “Muhammad will come to confirm which U(previous prophets posses)… that also means Muhammad was not prophet, because then the duty of Muhammad would be to confirm the previous scriptures not delivery of the new scripture, which is totally baseless and false.

3rdly, your created interpretation says us “You (prophets other than Muhammad because he is not encluded) shall believe in him (Muhammad) and support him (Muhammad),

[u]Here you agreed that Muhammad was a prophet but the verse 3:81 does not say that ‘prophets other than Muhammad shall believe in Muhammad.[/u] Also you committed a gross mistake here. [b]Please consider;[/b] Muhammad was the last prophet and he came more than 500 years after the death of Jesus, last prophet before Muhammad. [b]Then how could ALL PROPHETS SUPPORT & BELIEVE MUHAMMAD, WHEN THEY ALL ARE DEAD WHEN MUHAMMAD CAME?????[/b]

[u]And for this reason I told you again & again that Almighty Allah did not take the said covenant in this world, becaus all the prophets were not came altogether in this world at a time.[/u]

Fourthly, he said “ do u (prophets other than Muhammad) agree with this, and pledge to fulfill this coenant?”. They (not encluding Muhammad) said, “ We agree, (prophets other than Muhammad agreed). He said, “ you have thus borne witness, and I bear witness along with u”.

Here also you done Same gross mistake as you did above.

Quote:  Allah did not take a covenant from Muhammad of such type, because there is no messeger to come after him. And this covenant is concerned about a new messenger coming.

MY REPLY:- [:p][:o)][:I] had GOD not told in verse 3:81 “He took the covenant from PROPHETS”…. ha…ha….ha…ha…ha…

Who said to you that after Muhammad no messenger will come???? Pl.see;

[red][44:5-6]   It is a predetermined command from us that [u]we send messengers[/u]. This is a mercy from your Lord. He is the Hearer, the Omniscient.[/red]

[blue][10:47]   [u]To each community, a messenger. [/u] After their messenger comes, they are judged equitably, without the least injustice.[/blue]

[red][3:81]   GOD took a covenant from the prophets, saying, "I will give you the scripture and wisdom. [u]Afterwards, a messenger will come to confirm all existing scriptures……”[/u][/red]

Quote:-So there is no such covenant mentioned in Holy Quran, as no messenger has to come.

[b]MY REPLY:- blind can’t see anything.[/b]

Quote: Brother I do not mean so exactly as u mentioned, I mean Allah can do so and as for our covenant is concerned see the following verse:-
(2:84),2:187,5:12,4:54, 5:7,5:14

[b]MY REPLY :- See my above reply in this regard.[/b]

[u]Also your referred verse 2:84, 5:12, 5:7 & 5:14 do not say us that God took the covenant separately one by one mentioned in these verse.[/u]

The verse 2:187 & 4:54 do not say about any covenant.

Quote: I don’t know what type of quranic verses u want to know that prove ur whims,

[b]MY REPLY:- I didn’t require any quranic verse from you to support my statement, rather I asked for quranic reference from you in support of your own whims, but I again say you could not be able to provide a single one till date.[/b]

Quote:- as several times all the members mentioned Quranic verse in the regard of subject,

[b]MY REPLY:- Then why could you not been able to provide a single one in support of your statement? Do you fear???[/b][^][^][^][^]

To be continued………..[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview