Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Dear Salman,

Quote;-A scholar however is a human, and despite his best intentions, (assuming he is well-intended) he can & might err.

An establish Medhabs can have err but if there will be 10 errs in it so we will do 100 errs.If still you think you will do less errs,so why don’t you first try to prove these Medahbs wrong with the help of main sources. If you could prove even 10% of their work is not according to main sources, than you can think of doing yours own way to follow the religion.It is just my argument, I am not trying to bind any one here.

Quote:-but following ONE scholar necessarily will unnecessarily make my view biased. A differing opinion will get rejected just because it was 'different' without seeing whether it is closer to Quran and Sunnah or not.

By following one medhab not means that one is following just one schelor, all four Medhabs have the input of many scholars up to 4th and 5th century of hijra and they have tried to refined these Medhabs to bring them closer to Quran and Sunnah through the best of their abilities.If any answer we don't find there so the current scholars of that particular Medhab(medhab one may belong) give the answers of that through the consensus.

Quote:-Well what if people having studied modern sciences come up with a research that the pillars of this mosque have become dangerous for the people praying in it?

First prove it then you are well come.But without proving if you will start your own work, so you will put your share in the collapse this building.

Quote:- Considering every differing viewpoint, as a "scheme for the destruction of Islam" reflects academic weakness on the part of our traditionalist scholars. If they feel there is a problem with other viewpoints, they need to publish material to refute that argument with arguments - not with statments such as this.

Funds to madersas here is contributed by the the muslims.Have you ever seen that they ever give any fund to these mardersas.But today which of the world powers are opposing these mardersas is well known.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview