Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Salam,

Q:-  After the Holy Qur’a#n, the Sunnah of the Prophet Muhammad (sws) is the source of faith in Islam.

R:- According to Qur'an your statement is absolutely WRONG. As per Qur'an the only religious source of Islam is ONLY THE NOBEL QUR'AN.

Q:- It needs to be appreciated that all higher religions, in addition to their sacred texts, have a set of rites, rituals, manners, mores, etiquette and religious practices. ….. Islam also has a set of such practices.

R:- Dear sister, don't compare Islam with other religions because the only acceptable religion in the sight of GOD is ISLAM. There is no other religion(higher, lower….ect..etc…)

2ndly, Islam has a set of rites, rituals, manner etc..etc… BUT NOT OUTSIDE THE QUR’AN as you wanted to say because Qur’an says us that IT is Fully Detailed, Complete and Perfect…..IT is the Only Religious Source(6:114-115, 6:38, 7:52, 10:37, 12:111, 18:27, 18:54, 18:109-110 & 39:27)

Q:- These practices are not all of equal importance. Some of them are considered mandatory while the others just introduce manners or etiquette or they are symbolic in nature, signifying larger realities of faith.

R:- Which practices are mandatory and which are etiquette….?? If you can’t prove it from the Qur’an, then don’t misguide others by spreading rumours.

Q:- Among all such practices and mores, the most dear to the Muslims are those that

• are essentially religious in nature
• were instituted by the Holy Prophet Muhammad (sws), (who is the only personality in Islam having the right to declare anything religious)

R:- Prophet Muhammad had NO RIGHT TO DECLARE ANYTHING WRONG OR RIGHT ABOUT ISLAM. Only Almighty God has the power to declare these. Muhammad followed only the revelations.

Q:-  have reached us through the reliable historical process of tawa'tur.

R:- historical process of tawa'tur is not any CRITERION of Islam. The Only CRITERION(Furqan) of Islam is Nobel Qur'an(25:1).

Q:- This means

1. When we say that the Sunnah has reached us to Tawa'tur we mean to say that so that such a large number of people have transmitted the Sunnah acts in each generation starting from the Companions (rta) that the Sunnah acts have bee rendered beyond any alteration in any manner). These practices are called the Sunnah of the Holy Prophet (sws).

R:- As I said tawa'tur has no value in Islam OR tawa'tur is not a criterion of Islam, for an example Muhammadans offer their salat in mixed tone, which reached us through tawa'tur. But Qur'an does not support this. IT(Qur'an) says us we should offer our salat in MODERATE TONE(17:110). So your tawa'tur has no value in Islam.

Q:- Since Islam claims to have been the religion of all humanity since Adam (sws), and claims that Noah (sws), Abraham (sws), Moses (sws), David (sws) and Jesus (sws) were ……. ………….significance to Islam.

R:- We are accountable only for Qur'an and nothing else……..

[i]to be continued...[/i][/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview