Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]In continuation........

Q:-  I'm Repeating Again that
"Quran has Travelled about 1450 yrs of Historical journey b4 Reaching in OUR hands". Am I Right or Wrong? If I'm WRONG then Give me your Reasoning BUT if I'm Right, then Give me an Answer that is ONLY n ONLY Based on Historical Facts.

R:- I already told you that previous scriptures i.e. Torah, Injeel etc..etc.. also the hadith of Moses i.e. Mishna, Zemarrah and the hadith of Jesus i.e. Trinity…… all these are traveled more than 2500 yrs of Historical journey before reaching in present day’s Jewish, Christians. Am I Right or Wrong? If I am wrong then give me your reasoning but if I am right, then pl. tell me [b]SHOULD ALL THESE BE CONSIDERED AS THEIR OR OUR RELIGIOUS SOURCES?? If not, then Why?[/b]

Also the HADITH OF OTHER SECT(S) e.g. hadith of SHIAH Sect also come to them through this history, continuity, consensus…., then [b]should all these also be considered as source(s) of religious law of Shiah besides Qur'an? [/b] Please give your answer by saying simple ‘Yes’ or ‘No’.

If your criterion(furqan) about religion is HISTORY, CONTINUITY, CONSENSUS then all the above must be considered as sources of religious law? Is not it???

[u]So Brother, History, Continuity, Conjecture are not any CRITERION of Religion(I think). Our CRITERION of Religion(Islam) is ONLY QUR’AN(25:1)[/u]

Also Qur’an does not support the  story of your historical journey. I have already given you an example (2nd point in my previous post) in support of my opinion. I am once again citing this;

[2:170] When they are told, "Follow what GOD has revealed herein," they say, "We follow only what we found our parents doing." What if their parents did not understand, and were not guided?

The above verse clearly condemns to follow the acts of people what their parents are following. The verse also Orders to follow only the REVELATIONS.

According to your criterion i.e. history, continuity & consensus it is logical to think that the PARENTS mentioned in the above verse are following the practices which reached to them through their previous generations i.e. reached through history, continuity & consensus of their nations. Then why this verse condemned to follow these acts of the parents? Moreover, the next verse says that those who followed the acts of their parents(which came through history, continuity, consensus)not the revelations are DISBELIEVERS, DEAF, DUMB AND BLIND…

[u]So brother history, continuity, consensus whatever you call are not the criterion of religion. The Criterion of Religion(Islam) is ONLY QUR’AN and nothing else.[/u]

[red]“The Quran Is The First Truth, Against Which Everything Else Must Be Compared. Nor Does The Quran Depend On The Opinions Of Historians To Give It Importance”.[/red]

Q:- I'm afraid, I can't Give even a LITTLE VALUE to your Above Statement. Why (on which BASIS) we Do Not Require to Get this Information from History that "the Qur’an is the word of God & the Qur’an was revealed to Prophet Muhammad.? plz Give some SOLID reasons for that?

R:- Pl. recall my earlier post where I told you as follows;

[u]“Brother, when you are not been able to hear, listen or understand the Almighty God’s word, then who am I??? [/u]

So brother, I do not mind what you say. Once again I say pl. see on which basis Believers believed or believe the Qur’an;

How are you certain about your HEREAFTER? What is your history about your HEREAFTER, which is not yet come to you?

Brother, do you not think that the WORD OF GOD is the SOLID PROOF regarding your religion, Islam?? Alas!!! I again say I can’t make hear or understand those who can not hear or understand the God’s word.

to be continued.......[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview