Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Dear Sher Ali,

You still did not reply my questions. Please read this.

Regarding the Book and sunnah as authorities I believe that the Book of Allah is to be preferred to all. If the purport of a sunnah and hadeeth is not opposed to the Book of Allah, it would be accepted as authoritative, but we will not accept an interpretation of a sunnah and hadeeth which is opposed to the clear text of the Holy Quran. In what discourse apart from Allah and His commandments will they believe? (45: 7). This means that if the Holy Quran is conclusive and positive about a matter and its meaning is clear, a believer should not accept a hadeeth which is clearly opposed to it.

As all this activity was ex post factum, it was no more than conjecture; yet it would be most unfair to say that sunnah and ahadeeth are vain and useless and false. So much care was taken in compiling the ahadeeth, and such research and criticism were employed in the task, that they cannot be matched in any other religion. The Jews also had compilations of hadeeth and Jesus was opposed by that sect of the Jews who followed the ahadeeth, but it is not proved that the Jewish compilers of hadeeth had exercised that care in compiling their collections as the Muslim compilers of hadeeth did.
Say 'If you love Allah, follow me; then will Allah love you and forgive you your sins.' And Allah is Most Forgiving and Merciful. (3:31)
  
The correct way, therefore, is neither to treat the Sunnah and ahadeeth as having greater authority than the Quran, as do the Ahl-i-hadeeth of this age, and not to prefer the statements in the ahadeeth which are contradictory of the Quran to the Quran itself; nor to regard the ahadeeth as vain and false as is the belief of Ahl-i-Quran.

And finally brother please does not be in doubt. Quran says, And most of them follow only conjecture. Surely, conjecture avails naught against the truth. Verily, Allah is well aware of what they do. (10:36)

I again ask you some questions?

How may Rakaat you pray in Fajar and other prayers?
Did you recite “Darood Shareef” and “Ath a iat” in your prayers? 
How you do “Wudu”?
How much you pay Zakat, What is basis of this calculation?
What are processes of Pilgrim (Hajj) according to you?
Did all four Imams and ohte millions of nobel peoples who followed Sunanh and “Ahadith e Sahihah” were not pious according to you?[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview