Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Dear brother Abrar,

Please at first try to give your reply to my questions which I posed before you through my earlier mail. Please also read my opinion in the above post and if you think that I am wrong, then please give any or some reference(s) from the Quran in support of your opinion that I am  wrong. I want [b]ONLY QURANIC REFERENCE, because IT IS THE FURQAN(CRITERION) OF OUR RELIGION ISLAM.[/b]

I believe in the WHOLE QUR’AN like a believer do. At first I took the responsibility to convince the ‘Muhammadan’ through this forum, If I successful, then I shall InshAllah try to convince the Ethetics.

Q:- Please not hare that I am not saying that Ahadiths are equal to Quran. Quran is ultimate guidence and we should reject all those Ahadiths which are against Quran.

R:- Then [u]do you ready to reject the Ahadith which say that Juhr, Asr, 3rd unit of Maghrib and 3rd & 4th unit of Eesha prayers should be offered in SILENCE TONE(Note Moderate Tone), when Qur’an says that we should offer our salat in moderate tone(17:110)[/u]???

[u]Do you ready to reject the Ahadith, which instruct you MORE STEPS IN ABLUTION(WUDU) THAN THE STEPS DECREED BY THE QUR’AN[/u]???

Q:- But Ahadiths are also a great treasure and most part is good. So we should accept those part which are not againt Quran and Shariah.

R:- Which part is brother? Pl. give any reference. More over what is good and what is bad are not the matter. [u]The v.v. important matter is here ‘ALMIGHTY GOD TOLD US IN QUR’AN THAT WE SHOULD NOT SEEK ANY OTHER SOURCE AS OUR SOURCE OF LAW BESIDES QUR’AN & IT IS FULLY DETAILED, PERFECT AND COMPLETE(6:114-115). We should only abide by these words of Almighty God. We must not take any other thing/source AS OUR SOURCE OF ISLAMIC LAW. [/u] So what is the good and what is the bad are not any matter here.

We can read anything  but can’t take them as SOURCE OF ISLAMIC LAW. This is the TRUTH, whether you accept or not will not change anything.

Q:- You know, in these days many non muslims are so rigid that they deny all prophecies of Quran, although Quran is full of Prophecies.

R:- [u]Brother is this way As ahadith followers, may be you, deny the prophecies of 3:82[/u]?

Q:- Hope you will not so rigid and atleast accpet those prophecies mentioned in Ahadiths.

R:- For your kind info. I am saying you that [b]I do not accept any prophecies mentioned in your fabricated Ahadiths OR it will be most right to say that I THREW ALL YOUR AHADITH(fabricated and falsely attributed on Prophet Muhammad) TO THE DUSTBIN.[/b]Do you feel sorrow brother to hear this??? I can't do anything because it is the fact.

[b]I ACCEPT ONLY THE QUR’AN AND QURANIC PROPHECIES[/b].

Samsher.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview