Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Salam to All,

I am sending my opinion here against Br.ibraheem, the moderator’s two false claims, which are follows;

[b]He claims[/b];

In ALL "Sunan" (Practical matters of Islam) Muslim Ummah Does NOT need any EVIDENCE from Quran. they JUST need the "Ijmaa" (Consensus) & "Tawaatur" (continuity) JUST like they Need these TWO for the Whole Quran.

[u][b]MY Opinion[/b][/u]:

According to the Quran following the crowd or majority or the consensus of people to find the truth is wrong. There are numerous verses of the Quran condemning such a mentality e.g. 6:116, 12:103 & 106 etc..etc..
 
Before Galileo Christiendom had consensus regarding flat earth.
Catholics have consensus regarding the deity of Jesus and Mary.
 
Then, why could those who call themselves Sunni or Shiite not have similarly false ideas?
 
Furthermore, what is the definition of consensus? If you exclude those who disagree with a particular group as heretics, then consensus is a sectarian trick.

[b]Moderator’s claim[/b]:

"Tawaatur" needs NO authentication Bcoz there is Nothing MORE authentic in this World than a Tawaatur. For Example How authentic is Quran in your Opinion? It's the Best Example of Tawaatur & in Fact All Examples of Tawaatur r as authentic as Quran is. That's Y I always ASK all people Like U, that if not VIA Tawaatur then How this 1428 yr OLD Quran has Reached in your Hands?

[u][b]My Opinion[/b][/u]:

This is a lie. First of all, if one's belief and trust in the Quran is based on tawatur of some people, the source of faith and trust is misplaced. That person is muslim because of the crowd, or the number of heads. The followers of all false religions use EXACTLY the same reason to justify the fabricated lies about God. 
 
As for the Quran's authenticity; it did not needed people, especially those who fabricated volumes of hadith and contradictory sectarian laws. The Quran is divinely protected via an internal mathematical system. Despite some errors or temperance committed by previous generations, the divine protective system embedded in the Quran, authenticates the Quran.

Samsherali[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview