Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]WS perv1
[quote]My friend I do not completely agree with S Ali. However I am not sure what is your point here. 
Briefly: the Quran since its revelation has reached us in writen form. Although there are many who have memorised it by heart and continue to do so today and will do in the future. Also the actual content is accepted by all the so called sects. If you are trying to use the above point to justify the existance of Sunnah then I am afraid it is very weak or perhaps a non existant point. Perhaps you could clarify exactly the point you are trying to illustrate.[/quote]Brother, Plz Note that the PRESNET WRITTEN form of Quran Has Come into being after SEVERAL developments & the Written form in the Era of Prophet is Such that EVEN me CANNOT read it Properly DESPITE being a HAFIZ of Quran & Despite been Able to READ Arabic without "Ieraab" (Text w.out Vowels)
So I JUST want to Convey that regarding Quran at least Following things has Reached us By the Consensus n Continuity i.e. by "Ijmaa & Tawatur"

Its 'TEXT' from "al-Hamd to wan-Naas"
Its 'Method of Reading' i.e. How to read that Text. For Example the Writing of 1st word of 3rd verse of 1st Surah can be Read in MANY ways but thru "Ijmaa & Tawatur" there is Only ONE reading of IT & that is; Maaliki ...
Its 'Order'
& Our Claim is that the Practises found in Islam (Practicle forms of Salat, Zakat etc.) have ALSO reached Us thru the SAME above mentioned Process & Only these Practises r Called "Sunnah" & Nor All Ahadith Bcoz Muslim Ummah has NEVER claimed that Ahadith too fulfill the Conditions of "Ijmaa & Tawatur".
So HOW do U think that My pt. is WEAK? or
WHY it's a "non existant point" in ur Opinion & Plz Explain HOW? 
Well I've tried My Best to Clearify My point BUT I'm NOT sure How Successful I am?[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview