Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]AOA Ibrahim

[quote] Brother, Plz Note that the PRESNET WRITTEN form of Quran Has Come into being after SEVERAL developments & the Written form in the Era of Prophet is Such that EVEN me CANNOT read it Properly DESPITE being a HAFIZ of Quran & Despite been Able to READ Arabic without "Ieraab" (Text w.out Vowels) [/quote]

My friend I dont wish to be rude (& I sincerely hope it does not come across as such) I think ou need to clear the confusion in your mind. The development of the language will contiue but the message will remain the same e.g the word car may gradually be replaced by small vehicle, ghari etc but the meaning remains the same & also the original form is there for the reference. Where as the practice of your so called sunnah can be changed without any references to the original and is no different to changing fashions. In fact your whole arguement becomes flawed when you see the practices being carried out which you claim are based on consensus. Each sect has developed his own practices with no references other than what they may claim to be he consensus of this group.
In fact the corruption in Islam, prior to prophet Mohd, occured by so called consensus of the masses and the continuation of practices such as idol worship in mecca. Despite Allah eliminating such practices by sending the Quran you wish to go along the path of pre Quranic days by your so called extra quranic sunnah. Despite the obvious evidence in front of you that it has brought nothing but division and corruption in Islam you still continue to follow it. That is your choice but it has neither any logical or Qurqnic basis for it.
regards[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview