Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Salam brother Ibrahim,

I have already replied to your question, but you did not like that or may be you did not want to understand my point, then what can I do brother??? I am here to give the reply of questions according to Qur’an not according to person’s whims like yours. So if you dislike my reply because of this does not fit your whims, then I can’t do anything.

However, you tried to say that quran reached us through ‘continuity & consensus’ and also the ‘sunnah’(fabricated, as it has even no single reference in Qur’an, so I call them as fabricated) of Muhammad and AS BOTH ARE REACHED US THROUGH THE SAME WAY i.e. Continuity, Consensus, so you should consider them as Sources of Law of Islam!!!!

Brother I again say Continuity, Consensus are not any CRITERION(FURQAN). THE ONLY FURQAN/STATUTE BOOK in Islam is ONLY THE NOBEL QUR’AN(for ours). Also Almighty God says in Qur’an that IT is the ONLY SOURCE OF LAW (6:114-115). Almighty God also says that Qur’an is written in a perfect Arabic tongue. God is the one who is stating that, not me or anybody else. No Ijmaa or Tawatur is needed to read and understand the perfect, yet easy to understand, perfect Arabic Qur’an.

26:193]   The Honest Spirit (Gabriel) came down with it.

[26:194]   To reveal it into your heart, that you may be one of the warners.

[26:195]   In a PERFECT ARABIC TONGUE

[12:2]   We have revealed it an Arabic Quran, that you may understand.

[54:17, 22, 32, 40]   We made the Quran EASY TO LEARN. Does any of you wish to learn?

Qur’an is the Only Criterion, not because it reached to us through your continuity, consensus!! Qur’an is the Furquan/Criterion because ALMIGHTY GOD SAYS SO IN THE QUR’AN, but in favour of your fabricated sunnah, Qur’an did not say even a single word. Continuity, Consensus are two words which you people invented to justify yours claim. The followers of other religions (Jewish, Christians, Hindus…) use EXACTLY the same reason(like your continuity, consensus) to justify their fabricated lies about God and their religions.

Before Galileo Christiendom had consensus regarding FLAT EARTH. 
Catholics have consensus regarding the deity of Jesus and Mary.

Then, why could those who call themselves Sunni or Shiite not have similarly false ideas?

Furthermore, what is the definition of consensus? If You Exclude Those Who Disagree With A Particular Group As Heretics, Then Consensus Is A Sectarian Trick.

Now I ask you a question, do you believe that ONLY because of your Twatur, Ijmaa, your Qur’an reached to you? OR do you believe/think  that besides these two(twatur, Ijmaa), Qur’an could not be reached to you or can’t be reached to future generations???

MY OPINION:

I think as Qur’an does not support your theory that It reached  us or will be reached to future generations through continuity, consensus, so I can’t believe on these two.

I believe that it is ALMIGHTY GOD, WHO TOOK THE RESPONSIBILITY TO PRESERVE THE MESSAGE(QUR’AN) TILL THE END OF THE WORLD AND IN THIS WAY THE QUR’AN REACHED TO US AND WILL BE REACHED TO FUTURE GENERATIONS.

I also believe that ‘if one’s belief and trust in the Qur’an is based on Tawatur & Ijmaa of some people, then THE SOURCE OF FAITH AND TRUST IS MISPLACED’.

to be continued....[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview