Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Dr.Rishad

Once There was a dispute between a muslim and a jew. The muslim person ask the geo,shall see Prophet Muhammed(pbuh) to settle this dispute amongst us.The jew fellow agreed on that and they both went to see the Prophet(pbuh).What happened Prophet(pbuh) have decided the case in the favour of  jew fellow.They both came out .The muslim fellow ask the jew  that he wish to see Umer(RA) for his opinion on that.The jew fellow got surprised and finally agreed on that.They both then went to see Umer(RA) for his opinion.When the reached over there and told him the matter to him.Before Umer(RA) decide the case the jew fellow told him that before they already have seen Prophet(pbuh) and He has decided the case in my favor but this muslim fellow wish to have yours decision on that.

After listening of that Hazrat Umer(RA) went inside and brought his sword and chop the head of  muslim fellow.What was the reason of chopping his head was not following the decision of Prophet(pbuh).

Your Said:-So its pointless getting into a debate whether Rasoolallah(PBUH) banned it first or Hazrat Umar(R.A) later.

I have first tried to educate you on that very humbly,we cannot  finalized any thing if it is the Quran,we need to see ahadith on the same issue as well to fully comply on God desire.But you still not clear of yours mistke.So it is not point less but it is very required.That was yours mistake and even after my humble explanation you still looking for yours mistake.

Yours mistake may be not that big as the above fellow did and got his head chopped but certainly it is also not that small that another muslim brother can not get angry on that.

Until now my intention is to save my brother(you) from God anger.How you see all this from me you know better.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview