Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Salam to All,

•Emphasis laid on Sunan by the Holy Prophet (sws):

Q:- The Holy Prophet (sws) instituted these acts as integral part of the religion

R:- Those acts, which are not found in Qur’an brother????

Q:- he preached and ensured that these practices were widely disseminated among his Companions (rta).

R:- He preached only Qur’an. He preached the practices which were found only in Qur’an OR which were supported only by Qur’an.

Q:- Most of them belong to everyday life, relate to acts that are performed in the public and are performed repeatedly on a regular basis. They are instantly visible in a Muslim’s everyday life and in Muslim communities.

R:- If Qur’an does not support the above practices (i.e. taking them as religious law), then these practices must not be considered as Islamic religious law, because Qur’an is FULLY DETAILED, COMPLETE & PERFECT AND ALSO WE SHOULD NOT TAKE ANYTHING AS SOURCE OF LAW BESIDES QUR’AN.

Q:- The Holy Prophet (sws) emphasized upon the importance of these practices

R:- This is your WHIMSICAL OPINION and it has no support in Qur’an.

The only Sunnah is Almighty God’s Sunnah. There is no mention of Muhammad’s Sunnah in the Whole Qur’an. Muhammad’s practiced Only Qur’an. So literally Muhammad’s sunnah is Only Qur’an and nothing else.

So the idea of Muhammad’s Sunnah existed separately BESIDES QUR’AN is completely a WRONG IDEA and not related to Islam.

Samsher, India.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview