Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]As-salamualayakum,

Quote:- I think we all are trying to say the same thing but in different manners.
We all agree that Muhammad's sws were not different from the teachings of Qur'an.
We cannot call them non Qur'anic; the practices have reached us in continuation as explained before.

Reply:- Then it can also be concluded (as per your opinion) that the teachings of Qur’an are not different from the practices(religious matters) of Muhammad and Qur’an teaches us that we should offer our regular salat in Moderate(audible) tone. So naturally Muhammad followed this. Then why do you offer your regular salat by maintaining Mixed tone,(for an example) completely violating the quranic teachings, which were not the practice of Muhammad??? Brother, don’t try to fix a label to non-quranic practices as Muhammad’s practices and also don’t give lame excuse that these non-quranic practice is the teachings of Muhammad AS they reached us through Continuity. I told several times that Continuity is not any criterion of Islam. The one & only Criterion of Islam is ONLY QUR’AN according to the claim of IT(Qur’an) [25:1]

Quote:- My questions to the brothers/sisters who do not believe in sunnah is that how do they say their prayers,if only they believe that 'salah'(five daily prayers) is an essential part of islam?or do you interpret the word salah in Quran the way Ghulam Ahmad pervez sb(late) did?
Certainly,just from Quran no one can say prayers the way entire muslim ummah says it barring ofcourse a few heretic and insignificant groups.
I am really intrigued by this approach and would certainly want to understand it.Just to let these brothers and sisters know that i have had the privilige of visiting 'Idara e Tulu e islam' of Pervaiz sb in Lahore during the days of my quest for truth.Unfortunately i could never meet pervaiz sb who had died in 1986 but am well aware of his line of thinking.
I will be very grateful if someone could answer my question.

Reply:- Firstly, You say what does mean to say ‘Sunnah’? Do you think that ‘Sunnah’ practices of Muhammad, were different from the teachings of Qur’an? I think Muhammad followed and practiced the Qur’an even without slightest alteration. So Muhammad’s Sunnah was Only Qur’an. So the fabricated sunnah, which have no references in the Qur’an, were not his sunnah e.g. offering daily salat in Mixed tone. This is the TRUTH, because [u][b]Muhammad did not follow anything besides Qur’an AS HIS RELIGIOUS SOURCE and also QUR’AN IS COMPLETE, FULLY DETAILED & PERFECT[/b][/u].(6:114-115). I hope that you know very well the meaning of bold underlined sentence above.

You tried to claim that ‘from Qur’an no one can say salat means prayers’!!! Alas!!! Then brother, how could you know that ‘Salah’ means Prayer?? Who told you that?? Is it your Hadith(fabricated)?? Also do you think that Almighty God ordered us in the Qur’an that we should offer regular Salat, if we want to be redeemed, but He did not tell us in the said Qur’an how to offer it, when He also claimed in the same Qur’an that It(Qur’an) is COMPLETE, FULLY DETAILED, PERFECT etc..etc..!!! Brother, do you not think that it is totally illogical. Think deeply brother.

Samsher, India.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview