Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Dear Waseem,

Quote:-Most humbly brother Usmani I disagree with this statement. We start with the issue of majority. we state 99% then we further say this is not 99% of muslims, this is 99% of sunnies, then we say this is not 99% of sunnies but those who believe in hadith and sunnah. So we keep changing the statistics till we can state they agree with our statement.

No I did not ever change my statement. I only clarify my previous statement. I already stated in the beginning that to me the which people qualify the criteria which was there in the hadith.(They follow my Sunnah and that of my sahabah).Sunnies are not 99% ,I think they will more than 70%.

Quote:-Brother, with respect, prophet pbuh made a statement about Muslims, did he specify specific group among muslims, shiaats say the kalimah, say namaz, fast,make hajj, believe in sunnah and even hadith, though derived from their own imams.are we saying they are not muslims?

To me shiaats,and some others groups did not qualify the criteria set by Prophet(pbuh) so I did not Included them in the majority group i-e sunnies.You always can have a different view but make sure you don’t set yours own criteria for that. Prophet(pbuh) did not say that others who are not in the majority group are not muslims neither He said they are muslim.So why should we made any statement of such kind.We should take the advice from the hadith for our following and left the remaining part for God,He is better judge to decide it.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview