Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]excellent post bro Mujahid and valid reasoning. The issue is hadith as source of religion. Qur'an is calling itself meezan,and furqan. to be those it has to be a comprhensive source of religion.How can the Qur'an be furqan and meezan if further sources of deen are following it. It negates its self.

Last point being that Allah chooses Hazrat Gabriel to bring verses of Qur'an to prophet pbuh. Great emphasis is laid on the precise nature of narrations.Prophet is asked to repeat and recite to make sure it is precise. Prophet pbuh asks selected sahbhi to write the verses down and memorise. Then we come to ahadith, we say they are also sources of ahadith, none written in the life time of prophet pbuh or Abubakr or Umar rta. narrated by individuals. Imam bukhari himself states that he rejected huge number of ahadith as weak and unreliable before selecting the reliable ones. We now say that these and the verses of Qur'an carry equal emphasis in being a source of religion.

The second point is that Muslims from all walks of life accept Qur'an as source of religion. The diversity and contradictions of ahadith are the sources of sectarianism in Islam.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview