Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Brother Usmani,you write;

Brother I am sure you have never study the sahabah life properly.For them there was no difference in the words of Quran and in the words of Prophet(pbuh).

First of all i would admit that i may not be as well versed with the life of sahaba as you seem to be but i can assure you that i am not living  in darkness.I have understood religious issues with absolute fairness and rationality by the grace of God.

Regarding your second point that for sahaba there was no difference between Quran and words of prophet Please have a look at the following hadith and think again about your claims;

Fatima bint Qais  narrates that her husband Abu umru bin Hafs gave her third divorce while he was in yemen.He also advised his relatives to give her some money as well.The relatives said that we don’t consider Fatima deserving of this wealth unless she is pregnant.When Prophet sws was asked he said there is no money and shelter for her.
When this narration of Fatima reached Umar ra he said that on the report of a lady I cannot leave the obvious directives of Quran.We cannot say for sure whether she remembered the words completely or partially.Umar ra then recited the following verse from Quran;
Turn them(The divorced women) not out of their houses, nor should they [themselves] leave, except in case they are guilty of some open lewdness.(Surah Talaq 65 verse 1).The above hadith is from muslim kitab ul talaq.
Can you see brother how clear sahaba were in their understanding of Deen and in their relation of Quran and hadith.Would you still say that FOR SAHABA THERE WAS NO DIFFERENCE BETWEEN QURAN AND SUNNAH?[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview