Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Dear Waseem,

Quran:-Brother Usmani, most humbly we are talking about the source of religion and openly accepting contradictions in it. How can then we claim authenticity of hadith as a SOURCE of religion.

That is why ahadith are classified in various categories base on their authenticity. There were more than 124,000 Prophets send by Allah for the guidance of human.There also those Prophets whom did not bring any book from Allah.So according to yours thinking one should not be follow them.I have red the Bible there are very few verses which are the direct Allah words.Most of the verses are from the Prophet jesus(pbuh)  or His companion’s words.But because of these things no one objects on its authenticity.The objection is because the kind of message and the teaching of it.Niether Furqan ever objected on this ground on bible.

You need to understand that the revelation of Quran used come on Prophet (pbuh)once in while so that can be manage to safe from any out side material and also Prophet(pbuh) did every effort to protect Quran even he did stop people not to write ahadith for a certain time.But even during this time the other means to keep safe the ahadith were never stop.On the other hand its was impossible to save the Propphet(pbuh) words.Whole what He used to speak in the matter of deen were ahadith.

Allah has used the Prophet(pbuh),companions of Prophets until the people of forth century of Higra the process of compiling the ahadith was going on through them.Weather we need to used the ahadith as basic source of religion or not see the Furqan for that if you are still not sure.But once you established through yours own study of Furqan or though the people who have very good command on Furqan then accept it.Now out of 100 qualified people only one person you find who says ahadith can not be the basic source and not giving any weight to rest of the 99 then you what I would say for you.

Quote:-Ghamidhi writes that when we are deliberating and researching religion sometimes people look at facts with pre formed ideas and beliefs, thus they try to understand new information in light of their pre concieved opinions and are unable to accept new information. It is essential that we break these pre concieved ideas and look at religious information without bias. We must seek and follow the path of truth.

I have my serious doubt about the Qualification(Islamic) people who are involved in the so called research in Al-Mawrid.Think what would happened with the patient whose surgery would be carried out by the people who even not have the simple MBBS degree forget about the trained surgeon.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview