Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Salam hk,

Q:- (sk p.s the Quranic ref given in previous pages re: the prophets' call to the people to 'follow them' obviously whilst they followed their innate guidance, previous prophets' practices and the revelations that descended to some of them-finally shaping out their practices called sunnah, which they continued into generations)

Reply:- It is our obligation to follow only Qur’nic rules, rites (according to IT’s claim) and nothing else. This is told in http://www.quran-islam.org/176.html  .

The only source of Deen for us is Only Qur’an. We should rule ONLY ACCORDING TO IT.(5:48, 6:114-115, 22:67). We are accountable only for Qur’an (43:44, 2:134, 2:141).

Q:- surely sahih hadith(in the light of the science of hadith by riwaya and darayah)) is the knowledge of the prophet sws,

R:- Smile. Another lie against Islam. Brother I tell you there is no science in hadith, which is also fabricated by later generations to justify their claim. We should remember that our ONLY RELIGIOUS SOURCE IS QUR’AN ACCORDING TO THE OPINION OF MUHAMMAD,THE PROPHET. Qur’an is Fully Detailed, Complete, Perfect.

Q:- but it does not add anything new to the basic sources of religion mentioned above . they do support them though;

Reply:- Smile. Then how do you offer your regular salat? I asked this question several times, but  you could not show any courage till date to reply this. You know very well that if you would reply this, you would be caught red-handed. Smile.

Q:- hence even if the books of hadith were not there, Islam would prevail in it's full fledge-based on innate guidance, Qur'an and the practices/Sunnah of the prophets sws.