Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote][quote]Good intentions do not change the nature of forbidden
	actions. The ignorant should not misconstrue the meaning
of the hadith and think that good intentions could turn
forbidden actions into acceptable ones.  The above saying of the
Prophet (saw) specifically relattes to acts of worship and
permissible actions, not to forbidden ones. Worship and
permissible actions can be turned into forbidden ones because of
the intentions behind them, and permissible actions can become
either good or bad deeds by intention; but wrong actions cannot
become acts of worship, even with good intentions.(3) When bad
intentsions are accompanied by flaws in the actions themselves,
then their gravity and punishment are multiplied.
http://www.jannah.org/articles/purific2.html[/quote]

What you believe to be forbidden action may not be forbidden to others. Whether action is right or wrong is debatable. Even if you reach a certain conclusion there is always possibilty of it being wrong. There are many scholars out there who have spoken in favour of suicide bombings under certain circumstances.

Here, we are making an assumption that suicide bomber tried to find the truth first and he reached a position in favour of suicide bombing. We are also assuming that his intentions were right and he blew himself up solely to achieve the pleasure of Allah.

On judgement day if God sends the bomber to hell; he would raise an objection, O my Lord, I did this act for your pleasure, if I was wrong why did you not show me right path. How do you think God would respond then?

When a Judge declares a verdict to settle a dispute between two parties; if his verdict is right he would get reward for it; if his verdict is wrong do you think he will be punished for it? Again, we are assuming here that intention of judge is good![/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview