Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Why is there a difference? It's because you didn't do your homework right. Firstly the quran only speaks about Muslims enjoining prayers, it doesn't state the method for praying. Our beloved Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) taught us how to pray.

Now coming to what you have qouted. Surah Isra (17:110); brother the following narrative of explains the verse.

Sahi Al-Bukhari Volume 9, Book 93, Number 582: 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Reply:- Sorry for delay.

Actually brother I did lot of homework, but it seems to me that you did not think even.

Brother, could you please tell me what is the definition of Method of Salat Prayer? Do you think that ‘what Tone(moderate or silent) should be used in recitation of Salat Prayer’ does not fall under the methodology of prayer? I think IT is and this is told in 17:110 and we must maintain this.

In support of your logic you cited a hadis of Shahi Bhukhari, which says:

This Verse was revealed while Allah's Apostle was hiding himself in Mecca, and when he raised his voice while reciting the Qur'an, the pagans would hear him and abuse the Qur'an and its Revealer and to the one who brought it. So Allah said:--

'Neither say your prayer aloud, nor say it in a low tone.' (17.110) That is, 'Do not say your prayer so loudly that the pagans can hear you, nor say it in such a low tone that your companions do not hear you.' But seek a middle course between those (extremes), i.e., let your companions hear, but do not relate the Qur'an loudly, so that they may learn it from you.

So according to your cited hadis Prophet(pbuh) recited salat prayer in moderate tone (neither loudly nor silently).

Brother, I also believed that prophet(pbuh) had recited his salat prayer in moderate tone &amp; I maintain this. This is not the matter of any question.  My question was then Why(big) muslims( including you, if you think you are a muslim) all over the world recite their Juhr and Asr prayer and last rakah of Maghrib and 3rd &amp; 4th rakah of Isha prayer maintaining complete Silence??? In whose fear they do this?? Has any pagan present right now brother???

If prophet(pbuh) could recite his salat prayer maintaining middle course tone(moderate tone) in spite of remaining adverse object(Pagans) at that time, then Why you people can’t do that/show courage to do that now??? What type of Obedience to Prophet is it???

I can pose various questions against this hadis and your logic. But hope this is sufficient for the thinkers.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview