Powered by
UI
Techs
Home
>
Forums
>
>
General Discussion
>
Query
Post Reply
Username
Invalid Username or Password
Password
Format
Andale Mono
Arial
Arial Black
Book Antiqua
Century Gothic
Comic Sans MS
Courier New
Georgia
Impact
Tahoma
Times New Roman
Trebuchet MS
Script MT Bold
Stencil
Verdana
Lucida Console
1
2
3
4
5
6
Message Icon
Message
- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF
Smilies
[quote]Dear lofty………. You told that “This verse was revealed in Makkah when unbelievers often made noises and even hurled abuse at Prophet or his companions when they offered prayers. As a result believers were counselled neither to recite in such a loud voice that would attract the attention of unbelievers who might interrupt their prayers, nor to recite in a voice inaudible even to people close by. During the Madinan period when the situation altogether changed, there was no need to follow this injunction. However, whenever Muslims are faced with the kind of circumstances which they encountered during Makkan period of Prophet's life, they should follow the directives laid down in verse you have quoted. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- In replytof the above opinion I told as “So could you please tell me now in the world at this particular point of time, the injunctions of how many verses of the Quran require to abrogate OR rulings of how many verses, we need not require to follow now????? You saw the first portion of my question but neglected the 2nd portion i.e. “Rulings of how many verse we need not require to follow now? So dear lofty…….. please try to answer my question clearly, which I posed through my previous post, if you know. Don’t provide me any weblink. 2ndly, no quarinic verse is abrogated ever and to learn this I need not to go any scholars or need to go through any weblink. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Your quotation “I told you excatly why Prophet and his companions recited their prayer in middle tone but you are asking me same question again above”. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- But …….. nowhere quran says that ‘Only for this reason, as you specified, Prophet and his companions prayed his regular salat in middle tone. 2ndly, you told ‘now it is not require to follow this injunction’ Where it is mentioned in the quran??? The rulings of 17:110 is in general. You told in your early post that ““Hadiths are only a historical record of Prophet's times, written by FALLIBLE HUMANS, it can never take precedence over Quran”. In reply to your above claim I asked you: “Then it can be expected that you offer your daily Salat maintaining Audible/Moderate tone as per rulings of 17:110 as you accepted that hadis can never take precedence over Quran. May I right??” But you could not give any reply to my above question. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Your Quotation:- Your next question however is pertinent where you asked "Could you be able to provide me the concerned verse of the Quran, wherein it says as you opined????" It would require me to write down a lengthy answer in order for you to understand me and quite frankly I neither have the energy nor time to do that. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- I did not want any researched article dear one from you. I simply asked you to provide me a single verse from the Quran. But you could not able to provide this and I am sure you can never be able to do that, rather you avoided this skillfully by saying the above. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Your quote:- I know you have been influenced by the followers of Rashad Khalifa or some other group who rejects Hadith or Sunnah or both (as is case with submitters). -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Dear one, I shall be very grateful to you if you refrain from such rubbish talk, rather you answer my question from the Quran. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Your quote:- You need to understand the difference between Hadith and Sunnah first, here is good link to do that: I am sure you will find answers to your questions in link below. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- For your information I say and believe that the only sunnah of prophet is the Quran and nothing else. Prophet practiced only quran. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Your quote:- Also (if you can read Urdu) there is an excellent book written by Maulana Maududi in defence of Hadith and Sunnah wherein he literlly battered the arguments of Hadith and Sunnah rejectors. The book is based upon a debate that took place between Maulana and a scholar who rejected Hadith. Get hold of that book, I am sure your outlook towards your religion would change altogether. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- You better ask Mr Maulana Maududi, if he lives, wherein quaran says about ‘prophet’s sunnah’? I suggest you Please Hold the Quran Firmly and if you do that, your outlook towards islam would completely and surely be changed. avi[/quote]
Mode
Prompt
Help
Basic
Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic
Show Preview
Share
|
Copyright
Studying-Islam
© 2003-7 |
Privacy Policy
|
Code of Conduct
|
An Affiliate of
Al-Mawrid Institute of Islamic Sciences ®
Top