Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Salam,
I second atifrafi. Lofty u need to have full evidence for stating a fact. where did the author u mention get this piece of information. has he elaborated on that point?

one will make many statements but you cannot accept all if one is mature enough to understand the consequences of anything said about anyone. Yes, one cannot be fully sure of the authencity of the Ahadith. But who are those who are not sure of it? those who are highly critical. I am not saying it is a wrong thing. Allaho A'lam. the point here is, even after one knows how much of hard work has gone in the compilation of Ahadith there are still people who have some doubts regarding even the Sahih Ahadith.

And here you are talking about an author who claims something without any evidence/proof (at least you have not provided them even if he mentions it). u r quick to caste doubt about the ahadith. but not so about the unverified statement of the author?

Do not take this negatively. but reason this. one should be very careful in associating statements to anyone, especially the Prophet (s.a.w.w.). Without doubt, he was also a human being. But not like other human beings. no one can doubt that. the difference between other human beings and Muhammad (s.a.w.w.) is his Taqwa. If our taqwa etc were equal to his (s.a.w.w.) then we would also be prophets.

The topic here was about love. I don't know much but i can use my reason and say that what one feels for another usually is not in their hands. If it is pure. if any wrong thoughts are associated with this, let alone acts, then it is haraam. Also, one should not start idolising the person. anything that creates distance between man and God (being ghaafil of God), that causes a person to start walking of the path of being devoid of God, it is a fitnah.

However, it is better to have an answer based in Qur'an. Allaho A'lam.

Fee amaan Allah[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview