Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]shah_625:

[quote] Secondly this is deen it's not like science where new experiments can prove the older theories wrong. Deen cannot be in constant development, it is complete and has to stay like that for eternity. [/quote]

I agree with you....let me further add,
what I tried to mention in my earlier
post: 
If you see all the factions (or so called faction) in muslim world ...all of them stick to basic pillars and principles of Islam (iman, salat, fasting, zakat, haj, good deeds with other humans, talking nicely, forgiveness, issues of warasat, wedding etc etc)....they all are same.....they cannot be changed.... only and only differece is circumstancial and situational in implementation.

for example: all muslims should go to pray (namaz) in mosque...[b]this is an ideal principle..[/b]..but 
now situations came:
 
1) somebody is sick...ok ...ruling==&gt; ..no need to go.
2) there is heavy raining outside...ok ..ruling==&gt;...no need to go..
3) woman busy with household job or with childern...ok..ruling==&gt; ...no need to go.

Now there could be conflicts in such rulings as well....[b]one scholar may say .[/b].. male has to go in rain if he has umbrella or something like that...
[b]other scholar would say [/b] ..no, it is not the matter of umbrella only , he may get sick from this rain ..so no need to go...

this is just an example...

so my freind !!! [b]circumstances and situations would always keep changing [/b] ...and so the rulings....

but basic pillars and principles would remain same.....

one last example:

At the time of RasoolAllah (PBUH)..Any  new muslim was not paying jazya(tax)
.... but at the time of Hazrat Umer..he started to take jazya(tax) from new muslims also until a little  time would pass and he would prove that he did not become muslim just to take advantage of removing jazya from him.....

Like in India many hindus become muslims in court, to have 2 or 3 wives..lols....u see.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview