Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Dear shah_625,

You are right that secondary level issue are also Islam. I think the problem is NOT in the &quot;disagreement&quot; but in the fact that most scholars are not willing to even listen to others point of view. There are many things which are optional or left upon us. Just for an Example, Qa‘dah (sitting in a specific posture at the end of Salah, before saying the Salam) is a Sunnah. However the supplications to be made during the Qa‘dah are optional and we can do any supplication.

Now issue is that differect sects have selected different supplications and they are stick to those. We should be clear that this is left upon us and we can do any supplication.

About your 2 issues:

I will not advocate Al-Mawrid Team's point of view as your concern is something different. I believe you are more interested in the point that what OLD Scholars say rather than the reasoning or logic behind Ghamidi Sb's point of view. If you want, we can share those as well.

About the issue of Hijab, as far as I can understand you are concerned about &quot;Face Covering&quot;. If that is the case than brother Ghamidi Sb is not the only person who claims that Face Covering is Not Mandatory. Many of the Past and Present age scholars also says so. Just for Example, Imam Abu Hanifa was also of same point of view. According to him, Face Covering was only required under some &quot;Special Circumstances&quot;

Many modern day scholors also hold the same point of view like Dr. Zakir Naik... There are many more, I am only quoting examples.

For your second concern about Jihad, I think brother aslammir has already responded to that in detail.

Edited by: atifrafi on Wednesday, March 10, 2010 6:35 AM[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview