Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Dear Aboosait,

I am afraid I am still unable to understand your statement. My confusion is there is NO difference between a non-believer and Faasiq....

I have many things to say but just for the sake of argument I agree with you that this SUFI belief is not RIGHT.... But, my question is again same... Does that make a NEW Religion?

Why can't we say that they are mistaken??? There are hundreds of differences between the most eminent scholors ( The Four Imams )... Does that conclude in the fact the either one of them Created a NEW RELIGION???

The differences were also present even in the Sahabas... Just for an example Hazrat Abdullah (rt) claimed that Last Two Surahs ( surah Falaq and Surah Naas ) are not the Part of QURAN.

I just want to explain one point... if there is any difference due to the  MIS-UNDERSTANDING of any verse or Hadith, We SHOULD not and WE CANNOT say anyone Non-Muslim or a NEW RELIGION as we don't have any such Authority

[b]safimera ===&gt; [/b] waslaam. Thanks for your input. In fact I also tried my level best of staying out of this topic but couldn't :)

I think that i am one of the BIGGEST Fan of Mr. Ghamidi... I have fought with several persons and close friends of mine advocating Ghamidi Sb, BUT here I too agree with you.

Intrestingly, I have learned this too from Ghamidi Sb that I have the right to disagree with any Human Being :)

If Ghamidi Sb has ever said that Sufism is a new religion, I cannot agree with him ( even if I am still a big fan of him )

I NEVER claimed that its NECESSARY to follow SUFISM.... but at the same time its not a NEW RELIGION.... There might be some differences with others BUT these differences does exist in all MUSLIMS....

Edited by: atifrafi on Saturday, April 17, 2010 5:57 AM[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview