Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote][quote] though yes, I understand it is not accepted as such by many devout Muslims [/quote]
I think no muslim scholar says that coffee is haram???

let me [b]modify[/b] my version about ijtihad:

1) it was not the case  that all scholars stopped ijtihad after 4th century. there were scholars like ibn taymiya or ibn hazam or ibn rushd etc were doing ijtihad.

2) Most scholars usually stopped to [b]reconsider[/b] any ijtihad done by earlier scholars. They considered that those ijtihad were final and no need to change.
3) but yes!! u r right, for any new problem, they continued to do ijtihad.

4) because they did not want to [b]reconsider[/b] the earlier ijtihad, the [b]new ijtihad [/b] they made, sometimes also wrong because it had dependence on earlier ijithad.

5) Earlier ijtihad made by  then scholars were all [b]reagrding the very BASIC of islam[/b]....so if they were wrong ...the modern ijtihad may have chance to be wrongly established.

haha!!! may be I could not make my point very clear in [b]my wordings[/b]....but I tried ....

. [quote] if I were to wear the hijab I would most definitely be the center of attention which I would gather is exactly what God would NOT want [/quote]

you mentioned good point here....but what I understood that Quran stopped women to become [b]center of attention by exposing their beauty[/b]...if they become [b]centre of attention by COVERING THEIR BEAUTY.[/b] as hijab..I think there shoud be no problem in that.....instead it could gain [b]more respect [/b] for them rather to be subject of hooligans....

GOd knows better

Edited by: safimera on Saturday, August 21, 2010 10:53 AM[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview