Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote][quote] There are so many questions and not many answers. [/quote]
 haha....salam

this is a big test for all of us. No doubt books of hadeeth gave us a big help and insight of islam and life of RasoolAllah (pbuh)....
but same time if you see many divisions and sects have also been emerged because of these books.

Anyway some scholars made very strict rules to sort out false hadeeth and hadeeth which are not false but its interpretation is not what generally percieved from direct wordings.
 and one of the big rule for it is &quot; aqal-e-aamaa&quot; (may be english meaning=common sense).

but if anybody tries to do say something against any hadeeth meaning (not against hadeeth, only against its interpretation)....then he/she gets bombardment from other scholars &quot;oh! u r greedy...you want easy life...u r selling your imaan for easy life etc etc&quot;.

Regarding authenticity, On one occasion I read Mr Ghamdi did the same (accepted hadeeth without explaining the daleel). In his book &quot;meezaan&quot;
, one hadees he mentioned correct and authentic but said it is for her special case only??
According to hadees RasoolAllah (pbuh) advised one sahabia to breastfeed her adult ghulaam in order to make her son.

I wonder why this hadees:

1) cannot be rejected on the basis of &quot;aqal-e-aamaa&quot;
2) may be some additional wordings of RasoolAllah (pbuh) had been missed or forgot by raawi.
3) may be the advice was in a negative meaning....
example: it is common to say that &quot;u will get it over my dead body&quot; which means I would never give it to you..it does not mean that you have to kill me to take it....so in the same way may be RasoolAllah (pbuh) said that in that case you have to breastfeed him, which is against the norms of islam, society and diginity of woman, so just forget about it.....we do not have any history record that after this saying of RasooAllah(pbuh) what she did or she stopped thinking to make him his son....

so sometimes scholars like Mr Ghamdi also kept silence on the issue instead of explaining on basis of daleel.

anyway down is the link....but if still you would not get it....then just goto google , write &quot;true history of islam , shabbir ahmed&quot;...u will get the PDF file.

[url="http://ourbeacon.com/wp-content/uploads/admin2/2007/08/true-history.pdf"]http://ourbeacon.com/wp-content/uploads/admin2/2007/08/true-history.pdf[/url]

Edited by: safimera on Thursday, December 02, 2010 5:58 AM[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview