Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]>>1st, I'm realy very sorry, If brother Junaid thinks that my words are HARSH.

Apologies on the continued sarcasm accepted.

>>2nd, I would like to [b]suggest [/b] that brother Junaid should initiate an [b]independent topic on BEARD [/b] where he should convey to us his opinion on BEARD. I've read in many of his posts in Hijab topic where he brings example of beard and then conclude some results from it.

Let us not digress here.

>>Surely we are also talking about Beards of Companions BUT what's the source for this statement that [green]We have not one companion without the beard or without the head cap and nor a single lady without the head cover. [/green][b]?[/b]. I'm afraid I'm unable to understand "[red]As for the exact source, the cleric is dead[/red]."'

The cleric, whom I could have called for the exact reference and who made the statement in one of his khutbas died about 1997.

>>You can't be allowed to ask "Given the ascribed sayings of the Prophet on the beard and the rulings of the four schools of jurisprudence, can you find me a single Companion without a beard?" because this a [b]CROSS [/b] question. You [b]claimed [/b] that [green]We have not one companion without the beard or without the head cap and nor a single lady without the head cover [/green] [b]NOT we[/b], So it's up to you to give its [b]PROOF[/b]. Isn't it like that?

Who is we? Are you writing on behalf of Ms. Saadia Malik as well?

I made a statement for which I have sufficient reason to believe in through sense and reason. However, I do not remember the exact reference. END.

You seemingly do not agree with my statement. I suppose we both know that for 'refuting' purposes you would have to put forward one case for contradiction. i.e., Proof by contradiction.

On a general note, I am afraid that we will not get far in the discussion if we end up in loops. Please read the write-up again. I will only respond if I deem an honest discussion coming forth.

If people end up writing lectures, then I am not interested. A simple suggestion in this regard is to discontinue reading.

Edited by: junaidj on Tuesday, August 10, 2004 12:32 AM[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview