Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]>> In Tibet polyandry is practiced, they think its very natural. In east Asia, dogs and cats are eaten, it is considered natural.

And that for sure is a deviation. We trace our natural prohibitions all the way upto Adam. Adam was not misguided in this regard. If one retains the inner purity, one can arrive at logical conclusions.

Let me give an example, here in the liberal West, despite all permission of lewdness, people still feel guilty about it, yet continue in their deportment.

>>Opposite example, letting the beard grow. If clipping nails and shaving arm pits and pubic hair is natural, then naturally one should trim the beard too.

one relates to purification which ultimately depends on nature, the other directly on nature.

Trimming beards is natural as well especially to keep it tidy.

>>Different people will say different things are natural. There will never be a consensus. Who decides?

The voice and sense within.

>>Now if you will ban shark, then it is only natural to ban 90% of all fish we buy (because they are carnivores). Right?

Being carnivores is just one criterion, the other is the way they tear apart their prey.

Hens and Ducks eat worms, yet we eat them. But we dont eat eagles and vultures.

If cows and goats were fed meat based feeds we would still eat cows, but not lions and tigers.

Same principle.

>>I differ with you on your interfpretation of 5.96.

That is the main area of our contention. If we disagree on this, then we will disagree on all else that follows. I suppose the matter ends with our disagreement.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview